Table of Contents
Key Takeaways
- This project involved a full roof replacement on a home, two sheds, and a boat dock in Russels Point, Ohio, after storm damage at Indian Lake.
- The homeowner opted to switch from a metal roof to asphalt shingles to reduce costs and benefit from the insurance payout.
- We installed CertainTeed MaxDef Miore Black Shingles and TRI-BUILT Synthetic Felt Underlayment for maximum durability and weather protection.
- Our team provided assistance with the insurance claim process through Ohio Mutual Insurance, ensuring a smooth and hassle-free experience for the homeowner.
- The project also included the installation of new gutters to enhance the home’s water management system.
Introduction to the Project
The Roof Replacement in Russels Point, Ohio project was a comprehensive restoration job following significant storm damage at Indian Lake. The storm affected the homeowner’s roof, two sheds, and a covered boat dock, requiring a full roof replacement on all structures. Working with Ohio Mutual Insurance, the homeowner decided to switch from a metal roof to asphalt shingles to reduce costs and benefit financially from the insurance payout.

Our team stepped in to not only assist with the roof replacement but also helped the homeowner navigate the insurance claim process, ensuring a smooth and stress-free experience. The new roof, fitted with CertainTeed MaxDef Miore Black Shingles and TRI-BUILT Synthetic Felt Underlayment, provides improved durability and aesthetic appeal. The project also included installing new gutters for better water management. This case demonstrates how professional roofing services combined with insurance support can ease the burden for homeowners facing storm damage.
Initial Inspection
During our initial inspection of the Indian Lake property in Russels Point, Ohio, it was clear that the storm had caused significant damage across multiple structures. The most notable issue was the metal roof on the house, which had been severely impacted by a fallen tree, leaving large punctures and dents in the roofing panels. This damage exposed the underlayment and posed a risk for leaks if left unaddressed.

The two sheds on the property were also heavily affected. Strong winds had torn off sections of the shingles, exposing the wooden sheathing and leaving the structures vulnerable to further damage. The missing shingles on both sheds called for a complete roof replacement.

The boat dock did not escape the storm’s impact either. High winds had stripped off shingles, making the dock roof susceptible to water damage from the nearby lake. Given its exposure to the elements, immediate repairs were essential to prevent deterioration of the structure below.

Overall, the inspection confirmed that the home, sheds, and boat dock required extensive roof repairs. Our next step was to develop a comprehensive plan for replacing the roofs and to assist the homeowner with their Ohio Mutual Insurance claim to ensure a smooth and successful project.
Insurance Claim and Client Support
During the project, we worked closely with the homeowner to navigate the insurance claim process through Ohio Mutual Insurance. Our team handled all the paperwork, ensuring that the storm damage to the home, sheds, and boat dock was fully documented. This made the claims process smooth and efficient, allowing the homeowner to focus on the necessary repairs without added stress.

The homeowner chose to switch from a metal roof to asphalt shingles, specifically CertainTeed MaxDef Miore Black Shingles, which reduced costs and allowed them to pocket some of the insurance payout. By making this switch, they were able to invest in other areas of the property while still getting a durable, high-quality roof. Our expertise in managing both the roofing work and the insurance process ensured that the homeowner received maximum financial benefit from the claim and a roof built to last.
Getting Rid of the Old Roofs
The first major task for this project was removing the old, damaged roofs from the home, sheds, and boat dock. Our team began by tackling the house, where the existing metal roof had suffered extensive storm damage, including large dents and punctures from a fallen tree. We carefully removed the metal panels to prevent further damage to the structure, as seen in the first image. This process required precision to ensure that the underlying sheathing remained intact while disposing of the bulky metal materials.

Once the house’s roof was stripped, we discovered areas of damaged sheathing that needed replacement. Exposing the sheathing was essential to evaluate the overall condition of the roof deck and ensure it was ready for the installation of new CertainTeed shingles. In the second photo, you can see the exposed sheathing, showing how some sections required additional attention before moving forward with the underlayment.

We then turned our attention to the two sheds on the property, which had suffered shingle loss due to high winds.

Both sheds required complete shingle removal, revealing the worn wood underneath. The third and fourth photos highlight the state of the sheds after the old roofing materials were taken off, showing the exposed sheathing that needed repair in certain spots before re-roofing.

The final part of the job involved the boat dock, where strong winds had ripped away sections of shingles. The dock’s location next to the water presented unique challenges, but our team carefully removed the old roof while ensuring the structure below remained unharmed. The fifth photo shows the dock’s roof, stripped down and ready for the next phase of installation. This thorough removal process set the stage for installing new, weather-resistant materials across all three structures.

Repairing and Replacing the Sheathing
Once the old roofing materials were removed, it became clear that several sections of the home’s sheathing had suffered damage and required replacement before installing the new roof. The storm had caused areas of the sheathing to weaken, leaving the structure vulnerable. In the first image, you can see our team carefully removing the damaged sections and installing new plywood sheathing to reinforce the roof.

This process involved meticulous work to ensure the sheathing was level and securely attached. Any weak or rotted sections were removed and replaced with new, durable plywood, providing a solid foundation for the underlayment and shingles. The second aerial view photo showcases the extent of the work, with multiple sections of the roof stripped down and being prepped for re-sheathing.

The integrity of the sheathing is essential for the long-term performance of the roof, as it serves as the base layer that supports the entire roofing system. By addressing these structural issues during the project, we ensured the roof would be strong and ready for the next phase: installing the TRI-BUILT synthetic underlayment and CertainTeed MaxDef shingles.
Installing the Underlayment
With the old roofs removed and new sheathing in place, our team moved on to installing TRI-BUILT Synthetic Felt underlayment. This high-performance synthetic material was selected for its durability and excellent moisture resistance, making it the perfect choice for the house, sheds, and boat dock near Indian Lake. The underlayment serves as a critical barrier between the wood sheathing and the shingles, protecting the roof from water infiltration.

In the first photo, you can see the underlayment applied to the boat dock, ensuring the structure is sealed from potential water damage. Given the dock’s proximity to the water, it was essential to use a product that would withstand frequent exposure to moisture while still providing a solid base for the shingles.

The second photo shows the underlayment being laid down on the house’s roof. Our team meticulously covered the entire surface, focusing on sealing seams and edges to create a watertight seal. This step ensures the roof is fully prepared for the installation of the CertainTeed MaxDef shingles, offering long-lasting protection for the homeowner.
Installing the New Shingles

After preparing the roof with TRI-BUILT Synthetic Felt underlayment, the next step was to install the homeowner’s choice of CertainTeed MaxDef Miore Black Shingles. These high-quality asphalt shingles were selected for their durability, aesthetic appeal, and ability to withstand harsh weather conditions. In the first photo, you can see our crew installing the shingles on the home’s roof, starting from the bottom edge and working their way up to ensure a secure, water-resistant finish.

The second photo shows the work on the boat dock roof, where the same shingles were installed. Given the dock’s exposure to both sun and moisture, it was essential to use materials that would offer long-term protection. Our team worked carefully to align the shingles for both performance and visual appeal, ensuring the boat dock’s roof could withstand the lakeside elements.

In the final image, you can see the nearly completed installation on the main house. The CertainTeed MaxDef Miore Black Shingles added a sleek, modern look to the property while also providing the homeowner with the reassurance of a strong, weather-resistant roof. The installation process was meticulous, with attention given to each layer and seam, ensuring the entire roofing system would function effectively for years to come.
The Final Product

With the CertainTeed MaxDef Miore Black Shingles fully installed, the property now boasts a sleek, modern look, enhancing both the durability and aesthetic appeal of the home, sheds, and boat dock. In the aerial shot of the house, you can see the clean lines and uniform appearance of the newly installed shingles, which create a robust, weather-resistant roof that blends seamlessly with the surrounding environment.

The sheds on the property also received the same high-quality shingle treatment. As shown in the second photo, the sheds now feature a strong, long-lasting roof that matches the main house.

The fresh shingles not only provide essential protection but also give the sheds a cohesive look, making the entire property feel updated and secure.

Lastly, the boat dock received its own roofing upgrade. The third photo highlights the transformation of the dock’s roof, which now looks sleek and finished with the same CertainTeed shingles. This upgrade ensures that the dock can withstand the elements while maintaining a visually appealing appearance that complements the lakeside setting.
To showcase the final result, we’ve included a video that gives a full view of the completed roof on the home. The video highlights the impressive transformation, capturing the durability and elegance of the new shingles, as well as the overall improvement to the property. This visual tour provides a closer look at the workmanship and attention to detail that went into every aspect of the roof replacement.
Bonus: New Gutters
In addition to the full roof replacement, the homeowner also opted to have brand-new gutters installed on the property. Our team custom-fabricated the gutters on-site to ensure a precise fit for the house, as shown in the photo. This process allowed us to create seamless gutters that not only complement the roof’s appearance but also provide effective water management, protecting the home from future water damage.

The new gutters were an important finishing touch for the project, ensuring that rainwater is directed away from the foundation and siding, keeping the property safe from potential drainage issues. With the new roofing system and gutters in place, the home is now fully prepared to withstand Ohio’s diverse weather conditions for many years to come.
Conclusion: Project Success
This roof replacement project at Indian Lake in Russells Point, Ohio successfully transformed the home, sheds, and boat dock, providing the homeowner with long-lasting protection and a refreshed appearance. By choosing CertainTeed MaxDef Miore Black Shingles and custom-crafted gutters, the property is now well-equipped to withstand future storms and harsh weather conditions. From the initial storm damage assessment to the installation of new shingles and gutters, our team worked diligently to ensure a seamless experience. We also assisted the homeowner with the insurance claim process, helping them maximize their payout and minimize stress throughout the project. The final result is a property that not only looks great but is also built to last, offering peace of mind for many years to come.